[Internal-cg] Reminder: Action Items relating to Part 0 due by Sunday 27 Sept at 23:59 UTC

[Jennifer Chung]

Dear Martin and All,

 

This document is now in the Part 0 edits subfolder for your review and
reference:

 

Dropbox subfolder short link: http://icgsec.asia/1KyTHqT 

Document short link (renamed as "Part-0-Jurisdiction-text-MB-v1.docx") :
http://icgsec.asia/1NXmhYD 

 

Please let me know if you have any questions.

 

Best Regards,

 

Jennifer

 

From: Martin Boyle [mailto:Martin.Boyle at nominet.org.uk] 
Sent: Sunday, September 27, 2015 5:47 PM
To: Jennifer Chung <jen at icgsec.asia>; internal-cg at ianacg.org
Cc: admin at icgsec.asia
Subject: RE: Reminder: Action Items relating to Part 0 due by Sunday 27 Sept
at 23:59 UTC

 

Never let it be said that I leave things to the last minute.  My apologies
to colleagues - I failed to recognise the deadline was Sunday night.

 

I suggest that the wording for jurisdiction could read (also in the attached
word document:  Jenifer, could you post this into Dropbox, please?):

 

Eighteen of the 157 contributions directly referred to jurisdiction.  Of
these, six (mainly from individuals) opposed the proposal for giving up US
Government control and six opposed on because they argued that ICANN and
IANA should be subject to international law and jurisdiction.  Five agreed
that the approach proposed by the CCWG-Accountability, that jurisdiction
should be discussed further under Work Stream 2, looking at the implications
of a transfer of jurisdiction following transition, while one supported
maintaining the jurisdiction unchanged.

 

The ICG recognised that there was no clear consensus from the comments
opposing the proposal on the grounds of jurisdiction.  This reflected the
discussion in the CWG-Stewardship, where the discussion identified that
significant and detailed analysis would be needed to assess objectively the
implications and benefits of a transfer of jurisdiction.  The ICG also noted
that the additional complication of a change in jurisdiction at the time of
transition of stewardship - given the implications on ICANN and PTI
accountability - would increase the complexity of the proposal and add an
additional risk in the transition.

 

Accordingly, the ICG notes that the CCWG-Accountability has identified
ICANN's jurisdiction as a topic for further work in Work Stream 2 (post
transition).  It believes that this recognises that a change of jurisdiction
before or during the IANA transition would introduce unpredictability (in
particular in accountability) and complexity at a time when NTIA is seeking
predictability and stability.  It recognises that jurisdiction remains an
important, but complex, issue that needs to be addressed based on a clear
assessment of the implications of different options.  The ICG agrees that
the approach identified by CCWG-Accountability is an appropriate way of
continuing this work.

 

I think that this is what we agreed at our session in LA on Friday morning,
but would welcome colleagues' comments.

 

Best

 

 

Martin

 

From: Jennifer Chung [mailto:jen at icgsec.asia] 
Sent: 25 September 2015 18:33
To: Martin Boyle
Cc: admin at icgsec.asia <mailto:admin at icgsec.asia> 
Subject: Reminder: Action Items relating to Part 0 due by Sunday 27 Sept at
23:59 UTC

 

Hi Martin,

 

Per Alissa, a friendly reminder that the following Action Items (from the
F2F and Call 23) relating to Part 0 are due by Sunday 27 Sept at 23:59 UTC.


 

M6: 7    Boyle to draft text summarizing comments and highlighting concerns
received re jurisdiction to include in Part 0. (was Day 1 action item 3)

 

The Secretariat has created a subfolder on Dropbox to collect all Part 0
edits (short link: http://icgsec.asia/1KyTHqT)  - you may either upload to
this subfolder or send us your document to be included as well.

 

Please let me know if you have any questions.

 

Best Regards,

 

Jennifer

 

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mm.ianacg.org/pipermail/internal-cg_ianacg.org/attachments/20150928/46be4796/attachment.html>