[Internal-cg] "Alternatives"

Paul Wilson pwilson at apnic.net
Sun Jun 28 12:47:55 UTC 2015


On 28 Jun 2015, at 21:41, Manal Ismail wrote:
> Dear Jean-Jacques ..
>
> At least this is my understanding ..
> I believe, but stand to be corrected, that we're not requesting OCs to 
> provide comparative analysis of the different alternatives considered, 
> but offering an opportunity, for them, to share any material they feel 
> would support the submitted proposal, to be put on public record ..

I agree.  It is an opportunity, not a requirement, to provide 
information about alternatives which were considered.

Paul.



>
> Kind Regards
> --Manal
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Subrenat, Jean-Jacques [mailto:jjs at dyalog.net]
> Sent: Sunday, June 28, 2015 9:34 AM
> To: Manal Ismail
> Cc: IANA etc etc Coordination Group; Paul Wilson; Wolf-Ulrich Knoben
> Subject: Re: [Internal-cg] "Alternatives"
>
> Dear Manal,
> I could go along with the compromise suggested by you, insofar as it 
> is about consolidating the public record.
> Best regards,
> Jean-Jacques.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> ----- Mail original -----
> De: "Manal Ismail" <manal at tra.gov.eg>
> À: "Paul Wilson" <pwilson at apnic.net>, "Wolf-Ulrich Knoben" 
> <Wolf-Ulrich.Knoben at t-online.de>
> Cc: "IANA etc etc Coordination Group" <Internal-cg at ianacg.org>
> Envoyé: Samedi 27 Juin 2015 23:42:31
> Objet: Re: [Internal-cg] "Alternatives"
>
> Dear All ..
>
> I had to leave the meeting before concluding, so allow me to 
> re-iterate the following suggestion in writing ..
>
> If we agree, in principle, on maintaining public record of the IANA 
> transition process, then the ICG, through its chair(s), may reach out 
> to the OCs with an email flagging ICG's intention to maintain public 
> record that supports the IANA transition proposal, in accordance with 
> Larry Strickling’s remarks at the "IANA Stewardship Transition & 
> Evolution of ICANN Accountability" session on the Sunday of Buenos 
> Aires ICANN meeting 
> (file:///C:/Users/admin/Downloads/transcript-iana-stewardship-21jun15-en.pdf), 
> where he stated:
> <insert relevant excerpt(s) if necessary> And consequently ask the OCs 
> to let the ICG know of any material their community believes would be 
> useful to add to such record (for example: implications of the 
> proposal, alternatives considered, reasons for excluding them, answers 
> to anticipated questions, etc ... ) ..
>
> Thoughts?
>
> Kind Regards
> --Manal
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Internal-cg [mailto:internal-cg-bounces at ianacg.org] On Behalf Of 
> Paul Wilson
> Sent: Saturday, June 27, 2015 7:19 AM
> To: Wolf-Ulrich.Knoben at t-online.de
> Cc: IANA etc etc Coordination Group
> Subject: Re: [Internal-cg] "Alternatives"
>
> Re
>
>> IF you considered other alternatives, WHY did you decide against 
>> them?
>
> I am happy with this option.
>
>
> On 26 Jun 2015, at 3:34, Wolf-Ulrich.Knoben at t-online.de wrote:
>> I wonder whether we shouldn't question the communities, in case they
>> considered alternative models, 1. Which were the principles laid down
>> to guide them and 2. What was the decisive point for the option they
>> have chosen.
>
> This sounds a *little* too prescriptive for me, in terms of the answer 
> we are looking for.
>
> Perhaps what Wolf-Unrich is asking for could be expressed as:
>
> “IF you considered other alternatives, WHY and HOW did you decide 
> against them?”
>
> Which I’d be ok with as well.
>
> Paul.
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Internal-cg mailing list
> Internal-cg at mm.ianacg.org
> http://mm.ianacg.org/mailman/listinfo/internal-cg_ianacg.org
> _______________________________________________
> Internal-cg mailing list
> Internal-cg at mm.ianacg.org
> http://mm.ianacg.org/mailman/listinfo/internal-cg_ianacg.org

________________________________________________________________________
Paul Wilson, Director-General, APNIC                        dg at apnic.net
http://www.apnic.net                                            @apnicdg



More information about the Internal-cg mailing list